Over the past two years, the Council on American-Islamic Relations
(CAIR) and its Canadian affiliate, CAIR-Canada, have filed a series of
lawsuits against journalists and others who have traced the connection
between CAIR and the Palestinian terrorist organization Hamas. Among
the targets of these lawsuits have been the Web site Anti-Cair-net.org,
the Canadian terrorism expert David Harris, and this newspaper and
myself.
On April 12, CAIR-Canada settled its lawsuit against
Harris. The lawsuit ended without retraction or apology by Harris. The
suit against Anti-Cair-net was settled a few days earlier. Although the
terms of Anti-Cair's settlement are confidential, Anti-Cair's Web site
has likewise issued no retraction or apology. The words that triggered
the lawsuit remain posted on the Anti-Cair site: Anti-Cair stands by
its charge that CAIR is a "terrorist-supporting front organization ...
founded by Hamas supporters" that aims "to make radical Islam the
dominant religion in the United States."
The lawsuit against the
National Post and myself was settled with an editor's note that
likewise offered no apology or retraction.
The settlement of the
Harris lawsuit should be of special interest to Canadians. David Harris
is one of Canada's leading experts on terrorism: a former chief of
strategic planning for CSIS and now president of the Insignis
consulting firm. His views are regularly heard on television and radio.
Now he has recovered his full freedom to speak and to alert Canadians
to the dangers in their midst. This should establish once and for all
that media organizations can broadcast his carefully chosen words
without legal risk.
These lawsuits represented a very
considerable gamble for CAIR and its Canadian branch. So long as they
lasted, it's true, they inhibited media organizations' ability to speak
about CAIR. But once they terminated, as they were bound to do, the
full facts of the case would become matters of public record.
By
coincidence, just as the Anti-Cair and Harris lawsuits were being shut
down, Yale University Press released the most detailed study of the
Hamas terror group ever offered to readers without a security
clearance. The book is Hamas: Politics, Charity, and Terrorism in the
Service of Jihad; the author is Matthew Levitt, the chief intelligence
officer of the U.S. Department of the Treasury, and one of the world's
leading experts on Hamas.
Levitt's book was excerpted on these
pages a few weeks ago. The Post excerpts described Hamas's
indoctrination of young people, Hamas' electoral strategy in the
Palestinian Authority and the close co-ordination between Hamas'
social-welfare projects, its terrorism and its overall ideological
mission of building a global Islamic caliphate.
But Levitt also
has a good deal to say about Hamas' operations in North America.
"[U.S.] Federal investigators have uncovered a surprisingly large
number of front organizations supporting Hamas in the United States,"
he observes, and proceeds to explain an intricate network of
fundraising and ideological advocacy dating back to the 1980s. One
Hamas front organization, the Holy Land Foundation, raised $57-million
between its founding in 1992 and its final shuttering by the U.S.
government in December 2001. Another Hamas front group, the Islamic
Association for Palestine, engaged in advocacy and propaganda work.
The
leadership of the Holy Land Foundation and the Islamic Association for
Palestine in turn interlocked with the leadership of CAIR. CAIR's
co-founder, Omar Ahmed, had previously co-founded the Islamic
Association for Palestine. CAIR's executive director, Nihad Awad, is a
self-described "supporter of the Hamas movement." Lower-level CAIR
officials have been arrested and indicted on terrorism-related charges
in the United States; one accepted deportation rather than face trial.
Nobody
associated with CAIR-Canada has been charged with any criminal
misconduct. Internal CAIR-Canada documents uncovered during CAIR's
litigation against the National Post suggested, however, that 70% of
CAIR-Canada's revenues were forwarded to CAIR in the United States.
Canada's
new federal government has acted decisively against international
terrorism. The Harper government has announced that aid to the
Palestinian Authority will be suspended so long as it is governed by
Hamas. Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day has added the Tamil Tigers
to the list of prohibited terrorist organizations -- a move Mr. Day has
described as "long overdue." And the days when Prime Minister Paul
Martin sought advice from CAIR-Canada have mercifully been left behind.
Now,
with these libel cases closed, Canadians can freely join a larger
conversation, not just about terrorism, but about the larger problem of
ideological extremism from which terrorism emerges. Canadians owe David
Harris thanks for winning that freedom. Now Canadians owe him something
even more urgent: their attention to his words and warnings.
dfrum@aei.org