Liberals, Conservatives — for the Desmarais business family, it doesn't really matter who is in power
The Montreal-based clan has been plugged into Ottawa for decades
Feb. 11, 2006. 09:35 AM
MONTREAL—One
of the juicier bits of political gossip before the election campaign
began was about the budding romance between Conservative MP Peter
MacKay, Canada's new minister of foreign affairs, and Sophie Desmarais,
daughter of Montreal billionaire Paul Desmarais Sr.
She was seen
in the opposition gallery during question period, she and MacKay were
spotted together in Ottawa restaurants and, according to one report,
she gave him a very public peck on the cheek.
Sophie Desmarais is
said to have met MacKay at a dinner in October at the Montreal home of
former prime minister Brian Mulroney, a long-time pal of her father's,
whose personal fortune, through control of Power Corp., is estimated at
more than $4 billion.
Where the relationship with MacKay might
be heading isn't clear. But it was enough to set tongues wagging again
about how the Desmarais family is never too far from the centre of
influence in Ottawa.
The family has enjoyed close links with prime ministers in a period spanning more than 40 years.
Desmarais and many of his executives were friendly with Pierre Elliott
Trudeau during his terms in office (Trudeau later served on Power's
advisory council).
Mulroney was a business associate of Power's
before entering politics, and his leadership campaign was bankrolled in
part by Desmarais.
Jean Chrétien became part of the extended family when his daughter, France, married Paul Sr.'s son André.
And, before he became prime minister, Paul Martin owed his personal
wealth almost entirely to a deal with Power Corp. in which he purchased
Canada Steamship Lines on credit.
The extent to which Power
Corp. has exercised real influence in Ottawa has been a matter of
debate. What can't be denied is its proximity to power.
With
the Conservatives back in government after an absence of more than 12
years, one of the more intriguing questions is whether the company and
the wealthy Montreal family behind it will be able to maintain the best
political connections in the land.
Political scientist Antonia
Maioni, director of McGill University's Institute for the Study of
Canada, says the Harper government will have a more "populist" tinge
with its heavy representation from rural regions. That may limit
corporate influence.
It's also possible that "corporate interests in the West" may displace the traditional influence of eastern elites, she adds.
But others who've watched Power over the years suggest it will try to
influence the new government in key areas of self-interest, especially
financial services and foreign policy.
Paul Sr.,
now 79, parlayed a small, family-owned bus company in Sudbury into a
vast fortune in financial services, newspapers and international
holdings. While remaining chairman of the executive committee, he
turned active management of Power Corp. over to his sons André and Paul
Jr., who've been brought along carefully and share fully in
decision-making.
The family is "discreet, low-profile and very
shrewd," says one Montreal investment executive. Power has rarely made
the wrong bet, and shareholders have been big winners from its growth
strategy.
The Desmarais family doesn't spout the kind of
knee-jerk arguments for smaller government, less regulation and lower
taxes often heard from corporate tycoons, notes one former media
executive who knows them well. "These are people who are interested in
social stability, because their business interests require it."
Among the companies within the Power empire are mutual fund giants
Investors Group and Mackenzie Financial and insurance companies
Great-West Life, Canada Life and London Life.
`The company has served as a springboard for many political careers'Montreal source who knows the Desmarais family
|
Through investments in Pargesa Holdings SA in Europe and
CITIC Pacific Ltd. in China, the company has forged alliances with key
players in international industries.
In the media business,
Power wields influence as a federalist voice in Quebec through a chain
of newspapers that includes Montreal's
La Presse and Quebec City's
Le Soleil. (
La Presse was a factor in the election campaign in Quebec when it endorsed the Conservative party.)
Behind the spread of Power's corporate holdings is a web of personal
relationships carefully nurtured by the well-connected Paul Sr.
Indeed, Power has such pull in Montreal that it's hard to find anyone
who will go on the record to discuss it. One Montreal public relations
executive likens this to a "code of silence."
Over the years,
Power's board of directors and its international advisory council have
read like a Who's Who of political and corporate power brokers,
including the likes of: William Davis, the former premier of Ontario;
Don Mazankowski, who was minister of finance under Mulroney; Michael
Pitfield, who headed the civil service under Trudeau; Helmut Schmidt,
former chancellor of Germany; Paul Volcker, the former U.S. Federal
Reserve chairman; and Sheik Ahmed Yamani, former oil minister in Saudi
Arabia.
Meanwhile, past and present Power Corp. executives have taken a prominent role in politics and public policy .
Maurice Strong, a senior adviser to both Lester Pearson and Trudeau,
was a top executive at Power in the 1960s, where he gave a young lawyer
named Paul Martin his first job.
Daniel Johnson Jr. was a
lawyer with the company before entering provincial politics for the
Liberal party and becoming premier of Quebec in 1994.
Power's
current executive vice-president, John Rae, was an executive assistant
to Chrétien before joining the company and then was a top adviser in
Chrétien's three successful election campaigns. Rae, brother of former
Ontario premier Bob Rae, was also part of Chrétien's leadership defence
team when Martin won a putsch against the leader in 2002.
André Desmarais has chaired the Canada China Business Council, an
influential lobby group founded by Paul Sr. in 1978 to promote trade
and investment ties between the two countries. (The current chairman is
Power vice-president Peter Kruyt.)
"The company has served as a
springboard for many political careers," says a Montreal source who
knows the family. "But it's a mistake to assume Power is a monolith
with a single agenda. This is a company with very different individuals.
"John Rae, for example, is extremely close to Chrétien and was his
leading strategist, but he wasn't close to Mulroney and was extremely
distant from Paul Martin.
"André, because of his marriage, is very much identified with Chrétien, but Paul Jr. is closer to the Conservative party."
Paul Sr. has not been shy to promote his own views. During the debate
over the controversial Meech Lake Accord in 1990, he used his
connections to both Mulroney and Chrétien to broker a deal between the
two to save the accord from collapse, according to authors Anthony
Wilson-Smith and Edward Greenspon in their book
Double Vision. The effort failed.
He was an outspoken voice against sovereignty in the 1995 Quebec
referendum, becoming a hero to federalists and an arch-villain to
separatists. So enraged was former Parti Québécois premier Jacques
Parizeau at Desmarais' role that he accused him of "spitting on
Quebecers."
There's a common assumption that Power
Corp. has "owned" Ottawa over the last 25 years. "I've been doing this
a long time, says one corporate lobbyist in the nation's capital, "and
no company has ever done a better job of managing the political
relationship than Power Corp."
But the company has suffered its share of reversals.
Federal regulators turned down Power's efforts to buy satellite
communications carrier Teleglobe Inc. in the late 1980s and also denied
the company's bid for a satellite television licence a few years later.
A bid to buy the Quebec television network Tele-Metropole was turned
down by the CRTC.
`No company has ever done a better job of managing the political relationship than Power Corp.'Ottawa lobbyist
|
Critics of the company's close relationship with government
point to two areas where Power's interests are closely aligned with
government policy: financial services and Canadian foreign policy on
China.
As a heavyweight in the insurance and investment
businesses, Power has lobbied against allowing banks to buy insurance
companies. Some bankers have seen its positions as self-serving and
have attributed Martin's decision to reject the banks to pressure from
Power.
A consultant's report commissioned by Power two years ago
slammed bank concentration in Canada and claimed that mergers would
lead to higher prices and reduced services. (It's not alone in that
view.) Another report Power submitted to the government concluded that
mergers between banks and insurance companies have been a failure in
places such as Australia, the United States and Europe.
There is
speculation a Harper government might allow mergers to go ahead. Power
spokesman Ted Johnson says the company has "no plans" to make a
submission to the new government. "Our views are very well known."
On the China issue, Power is Canada's best-known investor in that
country. And Ottawa has conveniently taken a business-as-usual approach
to concerns about Beijing's human-rights abuses and repression of the
pro-democracy movement.
While Ottawa has raised the human-rights
issue with Chinese authorities, it has done nothing that might impede
the bilateral flow of trade and investment.
That's just the line
preached by the Power-backed Canada China Business Council. In fact,
the council's president is Howard Balloch, a former Canadian ambassador
to China who articulated Ottawa's business-friendly policy during his
term.
"We know that (the council) are very influential and that
they have access to both heads of state," says Tibetan activist Tenzin
Dargyal, a defeated Tory candidate in the January election who heads a
Canadian group that opposes China's occupation of Tibet.
Power's calling card in China is the connections it brings, he says, what the Chinese call
Guan Xi. "They leverage those relationships to open doors in China."
Chrétien devoted extraordinary attention to China and led three Team
Canada trade missions there that included Power Corp. But while
business boomed, progress on the human-rights issue proved impossible,
Dargyal says.
"Whenever we raised the human-rights issue, the
prime minister would head off to China to promote business with his son
in-law. There was always a perception that business came first."
How much influence Power has wielded can be debated, but the close
relationships with past prime ministers clearly created at least an
appearance of conflict.
The question now is whether the company
will have the same kind of access in a Stephen Harper administration as
it's enjoyed for the last 20 years under Brian Mulroney, Jean Chrétien
and Paul Martin.
Rudyard Griffiths, executive director of the
Dominion Institute, a Toronto-based think-tank, says the Conservatives
will be wary of the kind of "overt corporate association" that hurt the
Liberal image.
"The Harper team has had some success at giving
the impression he's more of an average Joe, he's not a multimillionaire
like Paul Martin was, he didn't practise with a big Bay St. or Montreal
law firm, he came up through a very different system that doesn't carry
the same baggage with it. "
With a couple of brief exceptions,
Canada's prime ministers since Trudeau's days have come from Quebec and
have taken much of their advice and direction from a small group of
well-connected business people in Montreal.
Power Corp., as a place that attracted the best and the brightest, moved easily in that world.
Now that Canada's geo-political centre seems to have shifted to Calgary, it's a whole new game for the Desmarais family.
Peter Hadekel is a freelance journalist in Montreal.